The Night I Vouched for Jep,
Being the Only Honest and Truthful Account
of that Famous Ambush in the Mountains

by Peter Robbins

By the time they marched those poor souls to a clearing, sleet cut across our faces like shards of broken mirror. Tried to curl my fingers against the throbbing gusts. Didn’t do no good. Just made the knuckle bleed worser. Moon was up, full moon, the snow moon, all glowing and dark patches, a cold face staring through panicking clouds. Skeletal trees the fools didn’t even scout for snipers convulsed on either side, black branches arched to the breaking point like roof beams in a rotting church ready to collapse. Long shadows of them, long shadows of us.

Barrel of Jep’s musket was shaking with the branches. “What’s happening, Davy? I don’t want to be here no more.”

“You ain’t here,” I whispered back. “Neither am I.”

The Reb I’d been calling Captain Widebrim—not to his face, mind you, but behind his back—ordered us to make a straight line and try to act military.

Jep wiped his nose with his sleeve.

“I said military,” the captain barked, and the ruffians shuffled into a semblance of order alongside the real soldiers.

“I don’t know if I can do this,” Jep whimpered.

“We ain’t doing nothing. No matter what he says next, ain’t on us to do nothing.”

…

If first light gave any sign that the day would end so badly on the angry banks of the Little Dry Branch, you couldn’t have proven it by me. Dawn was uncommonly airish and melancholy, true, and a hint of burnt mist came drifting from the west, possibly from a fire somewhere far away, but it was all without evil portent that I could see.

Most people don’t like February in our mountains, even the ones born here, which is practically all of them. Too drab, too cold, too sad. But for some reason it always lifted my spirit to see the sun patch through the winter clouds and streak the dry slopes—now gray, now green, now brown and copper—like the frame pictures the rich fools in Bethel Ridge have. Except this one was real and painted, I guess, by God himself. If there is a God. Maybe it’s just nature. That’s what my older brother Eli thought, times we talked about it.

Jep and me were coming over a ridge from the bottom pasture when we first saw them. At least three on horseback. Maybe seven or so holding horses or mules by the reins. A large wagon with a billowing canvas loomed behind them like a coffin built for a race of giants. And guns. They all were armed. Old smoothbore Springfields like ours for the best part, that’s what I guessed. Maybe a couple long Kentucky rifles. But some looked to be serious weapons. The new carbines, I mean. Cavalry rifle. Shorter barrels. Ever since I heard about them, I was wanting to get my hands on one, not that I ever would.

Ma was out front of our cabin, standing them down in her sack coat. She wasn’t carrying her shotgun, so they must have taken her unawares. Had her back to us, waving her hands fast in the air. I pulled Jep down by the britches into the briars before he could argue.

“Bushwackers,” he whispered, but two things argued against that. First off, was daylight. Second off, they weren’t stealing or burning nothing. Just milling and shuffling aimlessly. We had our muskets and powder horns, sure, didn’t go nowheres without a loaded gun in them days, but they were too far away and we were too overnumbered.

We crept on our elbows and bellies till I could make out at least three uniforms. Real uniforms, I mean, not home guards. Sunlight flashed off the buttons. Couldn't tell which shade of coat and the colors sometimes played tricks when they’d gone faded, but was months since Kirk and his Bluecoats done any foraging in our hills. Only locusts now were gray.

When I told him, Jep’s eyes went wide. “You think they know about Eli?”

At the start of it, Eli lit out for Kentucky with the Lincoln men—the ones from Dry Branch, Duel Hill, Lonesome Mountain, up that way. Ma tried to talk him out, but he was all hot for it. Don’t know why. No Union never did nothing for us. Onlyest thing you can rely on is family, that’s been the rule since the days of Noah. But seemed like Eli was born with a need to get back at the world for something, and when the rich people in Bethel Ridge started bellowing about Sumter and Nigger Abe and his tyrant call for militia men, such as that, I guess somewhere a river flooded its bank.

Might could be well down the Mississippi by now. With Sherman or Buell or that drunk butcher Grant. Or maybe he was with the ones that whipped the Rebs at Knoxville. We used to learn bits of it from people in town, scraps of newspapers, but we never got any letters from Eli, and it had been almost a year since we’d heard much of anything at all. That was the worst part, the not knowing.

Not that I knew any better what to do right now. “They could be hunting for deserters,” I said, thinking out loud but keeping the other possibilities to myself.

“We ain’t deserters.”

“They don’t know that.”

If they took you for a deserter and didn’t shoot you on the spot, they hauled you to jail where Judge Baylock threatened to brand you with a D. That's what Ma said. Unless the family gave up a horse or a mule or something. Didn't matter whether you were or you weren’t, so long as your family had a horse or a mule or hog to trade. It became quite a business for him, but some of those people all but starved to death, left as they were to plow the rocks by hand. I didn’t want to worry Jep about it, but the Rebs were letting them enlist as young as fourteen now, so even he could have been mistook for a runaway drummer boy or bugler.

“What are we gonna do?” Jep said.

“See what they do first.”

That didn’t take long. Black shape of a man, rough man, not a soldier, threw a rope over a low branch of the shagbark in front of the cabin. Noose swung down, back and forth, long slow, long slow. Jep snapped to aim, but I forced the barrel down. I asked myself what Eli would do, and I got an answer sooner than I thought I would.

“Listen. We’re going to have to stealth our way out of this. Follow me and don't run. And hold your gun up over your head. Don’t do nothing till I do. Maybe I can get the bulge on their leader and if I do, I’ll threaten to blow a crater in his chest until the rest back off.”

“You think that will work?”

“Depends on how much they value human life. But at least it’ll give you and Ma a decent chance to break for the cabin.”

“But what will happen to you then?”

“You got a better plan, I’m all ears.”

For once he done like I said, and we got down the slope alive.

…

Most of them were just ruffians. Evil men, scavengers. Kind that followed the troop trains with the Sodomville ladies, yelping for scraps, snarling over them, admiring their pistols, if they could steal any. Never did no real fighting, leastways not face to face. And not for any side but their own. Hogs too numerous for the pen, Ma called them.

But the ones on horseback, they were pure regulation. Real uniforms. Genuine leather saddle bags. Sabers in scabbards. One who looked to be top dog had on this very fine hat, bright red feathers, pinned to the side, wide brim shadowing his face. All horsestrut and the spirit, lean as a bayonet. Three bars on his shoulder meant captain. Not sure where I picked that up, but something somewhere just shouted it to my mind.

“Well, well, well,” Captain Widebrim said. “It appears you have sons, after all, ma’am. Admirably loyal ones, I might add. Their timely arrival just saved us a lot of trouble.”

We held our muskets over our heads, and they pointed their guns at us, and all of us stood there for quite some while, and nobody seemed to know what to do. I shifted around so their backs were more to the cabin, so maybe they wouldn’t see the sacks under the porch, if that’s what it was about. Jep followed my lead, even though I’m sure he had no idea why.

Then someone’s head poked out from the back, and come to find Mister Odum leaning out from behind them all, and to say that was a relief would be only a half truth. Old Odorous Odum, Eli called him. Him and his skinny, slope shoulders, not a muscle in his body, perched on his sorry excuse for mule. Thought he was better than us because his people had a hotel on the turnpike, but weren’t much to speak of really. Didn’t even have no nigra ladies like the
Baylock’s. He showed up at our cabin every so often, night times usually, something to sell, something to trade.

Mister Odum brought his mule upside Captain Widebrim and mumbled some words I couldn’t hear, and I inched my finger around the trigger because no doubting Odum knew about Eli and the Lincoln men—and probably other things too. One soldier, towheaded one with sergeant stripes but no forage cap, came over by the captain’s side, and then the other one on the other side, and they were all talking low.

Then Captain Widebrim separated them with his hand like Moses parting the Red Sea. Morning sunlight hit his face just then, and an awful, distant face it was. Long jaw. Hard angles. Deep creases. Put me in mind of one of them new pocketknives with all the fold-out blades. He leveled an eye on Jep, long, slow, bloodshot, and sized me up the same way. I was about to make my move when he gave Mister Odum a sidelong glance, which I should have known meant no good.

“That would certainly be a diverting entertainment, wouldn’t it? A test of character, as they say, to enliven these degrading proceedings. An educated man might even call it—what’s the word I’m looking for here—irony? And I suppose it would be churlish of me to deny a small accommodation to such a reliable guide and collaborator. All right, then, we shall see how it goes. But they try to run or do anything misguidedly heroic, and it’s on you, my silver-tongued friend.”

Then to us: “Put your hands down, boys. You’re among friends. We had a little misunderstanding there for a moment, but it’s been cleared up.” He looked down at Jep with something that was either a smile or a sneer. “Lordy, son. That gun’s bigger than you are. Have you gotten it rebored?”

“What business is it—,” Jep started to say, but I grabbed his suspenders and pulled hard till he was all stumbles and back on his heels.

“May we inquire to ask why you want to know, sir?”

“I shall not inquire to ask a second time.”

“All they is is squirrel guns,” Ma said. “Ain’t no good to you.”

“Impressive squirrels you got here, ma’am. But rest assured, I do not intend to seize their firearms. I merely want to ascertain whether these boys will know how to use them when the time comes.”

Jep twisted free of me. “Know enough how to use them to take down your gray belly!”

Jep was small and redheaded and tight wound as the redheaded will be, but that outburst was a rabid badger even for him. I took hold of his musket barrel. “He didn’t mean nothing by that, sir. Sometimes he just says things without thinking.”

Captain Widebrim laughed the way folks do when they don’t really find something funny. “I shall be looking forward to that adventure, I surely will, but it will have to await another day. I’m told you two can be relied on to render faithful service to our cause. That true?”

This was another of those times I wished Eli were here to tell me what to say. My own mind couldn’t conjure a word.

“You’re making me wait for an answer? Another second I may change my mind.”

No cards to play. No choice but to gamble. “I’ll go, sir,” I said. “Leave him here. He’s just a boy.”

“Be thirteen in June, near old as you,” Jep said. “Where we going?”

“You ain't going nowheres, Jephthah Spillcorn,” Ma said.

“You don’t need him,” I said. “He can’t never do nothing right. Whatever you’re wanting him for, he’ll just be botheration.”

“Maybe they don't unnerstand the meaning of volunteer,” said a ruffian with a black tooth sticking out the side of his mouth.

“Where we going?” Jep said.

Captain Widebrim backed his horse a step and stared down Jep like he was addressing a backward child. “We shall be doing the Lord’s work, son. Make you fishers of men. I’m sure you’re all good church people, so you must know what that means.”

“Lessen you just want to die here,” Black Tooth said. “Shame to waste that noose. Tied it myself real good.”

Mister Odum pulled his mule upside me and swatted my shoulder with the reins. “Just do what he says, David. Don’t give him no trouble. It'll be all right.” He gave Ma the stupidest wink I ever seen. “This’ll count as one more you owe to me, Miss Mara.”

She shot him a glare that would have killed a rattlesnake. Odum held up his palms in mock fear. “Whoa, we’ll settle up later,” he said with a slimy smile.

“We’ll see,” she answered.

…

Me and Jep tied the hands. That was our part, leastways that was our part at the start. The soldiers and ruffians pointed their guns at us while we did it, and we were supposed to help the ones they rounded up get into the wagon. After we’d load them in, the ruffians gave us our guns back, and they’d move on to the next farm and snatch another one. But they kept a gun or two locked on us, too.

They commenced taking them in earnest maybe six or seven hollers down the road from our place. On toward the Tennessee border where the Lincoln people lived. I didn’t know many in those parts. Eli knew them better. Besides, I had learned to keep my distance from neighbors generally on account that sometimes they would make jokes about Ma not being married and I was tired of getting into fistfights. All but one of the ones they snared were strangers to our family, definitely no kin, so there wasn’t much risk on that end.

The one who did recognize me was Little Ezra Goforth. He was a kid about Jep’s age, maybe a little older, although I don’t think their paths ever crossed. He wasn’t a bad sort, I knew him in a nodding way, except now he greeted me with all the friendliness of a cornered copperhead. “You’re with them now? Really? You got any honor at all, Davy Spillcorn?” He called me a traitor and a disgrace to my brother Eli and some other things I won’t repeat, so I can’t say I felt over bad when one of the ruffians ended his oratory with a fist to the face.

Most they took by surprise. In a barn, in a smokehouse, a field. Easy enough to sneak up on them. Hills up that way slant so steep, like to lose your balance just to look at them. Didn’t seem particular about it. A couple went hollering, saying what I done, what I done, such as that, but most went quiet. Like they’d given up long ago and one way out was good as the next. One man, a really old one, had to practically carry him into the wagon. Looked like he was going to die right there, so thin and shaking. He didn’t complain, though. Didn’t even look up. Just asked Captain Widebrim how many they were going to take.

“I understand twelve’s a lucky number,” the captain answered. “We’ll aim for that. If we’re off by five or six or seven, you’ll forgive me, won’t you?”

Was their women were the feisty ones. One girl wouldn’t give up her brothers until they put a noose around her neck, and they eased her down slow and her eyes were all bulging and her face was blue, and she was just able to choke it out they were hiding in the spring house. She spat in Captain Widebrim’s face and cursed him for Satan. I think that’s what she was trying to say. She took a rifle butt in the face for her sass, and after that it was hard to tell. Too bad. Pretty girl. This other woman, older one, they tied her to a tree and whipped her with hickory ox goads till she was nothing but bloody rags. She sung hymns while they did it. Tried to. She talked when they twisted a knotted rope to her eyeball.

After some hours of this, Jep’s enthusiasm started to weaken with his legs. “Why they got to be so mean, Davy? Are you sure this is all right?”

I wished there was something I could tell him. “I never said it was all right. It’s happening. That’s all.”

“I’m scared,” Jep said. “Why ain’t we doing no fighting? These here ain’t even soldiers. When are we doing some shooting?”

“Whatever they’re doing, it’s got nothing to do with us. We’re staying out of it.”

“But these here—”

“Did you see what they were going to do to Ma? You want to get her killed? You want to get us killed? We’re staying out of it. Understand?”

“I don’t understand none of this,” he said. “And don’t yell at me.”

“I’m not yelling,” I said. And that was the truth. I was being quiet as I possibly could.

…

That towheaded soldier—the one with sergeant stripes and no cap—didn’t talk much. He had a gash under his eye with a steady trickle of blood running to the cheekbone. Must have been worrying him because he kept wiping it with his sleeve. When we took a rest a few miles before the Little Dry Branch, I finally got up the nerve to ask if I could take a look at his rifle.

“That’s a new carbine, ain’t it, sir?”

“Sure is,” Sergeant Towhead said. “A genuine Spencer. Don’t see it very often. Certainly not in our hands.”

“Is it true what they say?”

“What do they say?”

“That it repeats. That you can fire all day.”

“Well, not quite. Fires off seven without reloading. Seven sent to their maker ’fore you finish the first verse of Dixie. Not as accurate as the Sharps or the Enfield and don’t have the range, but sure is fast.”

Sergeant Towhead cocked the hammer, swung the barrel around, fired a shot at the air, pulled the lever under the trigger, and ejected the spent cartridge like a wood chip.

“Simple as that. Any fool can do it. Takes a little of the glory out of the whole affair, though.”

Captain Widebrim’s horse trotted to the side of the wagon. “But it takes a bona-fide, fourteen-karat-gold genius to waste ammunition like that, doesn’t it? What with copper so plentiful and all. Why don’t you just ride up and tell them we’re coming while you’re at it? Maybe they’ll have supper waiting.”

His horse snorted disgust, too. “You’ll come to nothing but grief if you listen to that one,” the captain said to me as his snorting horse stepped away.

“Peckerwood,” Sergeant Towhead muttered. He didn’t seem to care whether Captain Widebrim was out of earshot or not, but I did.

“Sure makes a lot of smoke, don’t it?”

“It does. Can’t hardly see through all the haze sometimes.”

“They issue you those?”

“Let’s just say we acquire them.”

He didn’t seem self-conscience about it, so I thought I could take the liberty to ask. “That how you got the cut on your face?”

I was relieved when he just smiled. “No, that scar’s how I got these boots.”

When I asked him why we were doing this, he said some foolishness about a rich man’s salt got people’s blood up and had to cool it off to keep the locals in line for the duration. I swallowed hard. There they were, the words I’d been hoping that I wouldn’t hear, hoping against all facts I wouldn’t hear, but there they were. “You mean the Baylock stands? The ones they raided?”

“Don’t know the bastard’s name. Don’t care, neither.”

“You know why they done it?”

“Not directly, but I reckon they didn’t cotton to rationing. Can’t say I blame them.”

“If they stole, they should pay for it,” Jep interjected.

“Be quiet, Jep,” I said. “You think these here done it? They don’t look like they got the sand to wash their teeth.”

“Can’t necessarily tell by the surface,” Sergeant Towhead said. “The muck is always on the bottom.”

“Those murdering murderers killed people,” Jep said. “If they were in on it, they deserve to—”

“I said shut up, Jep. But if it comes out they didn’t do it, they’ll let them go, right? That’s justice, ain’t it?”

“I got to repeat myself? I don’t care.”

Weren’t no fit duty for a soldier, he said, but orders were orders, except pretty soon there wouldn’t be any orders as he was planning to slip off first chance he got to rejoin his wife and a firstborn he ain’t never even seen yet. I asked where that was, but he wouldn’t say. Just said something strange about people having longer memories than they need.

…

Long about sunset, the wagon was getting too full up, way too full up, digging into the frozen ruts and wobbling and all, even the most addled jackleg should have seen that. The human cargo barely had room to sit, crammed together like meat in a smokehouse. But Captain Widebrim didn’t pay any mind, hellbent as he was to get on with it and weren’t nobody in that crew man enough to argue the point. When the wagon heaved, they made us—Jep and me and the ruffians—pull off the canvas, and haul the tangled wretches out one by one, and then push the wagon back up.

“This is our chance,” I whispered to Jep. “When it’s up and they’re distracted, run to that tree stand yonder. With luck, we can slip away without nobody seeing us.”

But turned out I was the one distracted. Maybe it was the strain of the situation or maybe it was something else, but my thinking had become a string of brush fires, what with me watching for every angle, trying to keep every option open, and I didn’t notice that my hand had slipped between the hub and the boxing on the wheel. When the wagon yanked up, the middle finger on my left hand got caught. Never had a knuckle break before so I don’t know what it feels like exactly, but when I tried to flex, hellfire flashed through my whole arm. My finger started to swell up almost immediately, and all I could do was look down at my musket on the ground and think how helpless we’d be if it came down to it and I couldn’t even grip the stock.

Captain Widebrim was behind me before I knew it. “Excellent work, gentlemen. Our assignment is nearly completed. You can expect your reward directly. Now pick up these rolling sacks and get them back in the wagon. We can’t have them dying just yet.”

Wincing in pain, I showed him my swelling hand and asked if me and Jep could go home to attend to it. “We can just go on foot,” I said. “Ain’t that far.”

The captain smiled. “I understand your concern, but it wouldn’t be right to leave behind any innocents to bear false witness, now would it? I’ll let you and your little brother know when your enlistments have expired. Until then, you’re mine.”

“What’s that supposed to mean?” I said, immediately regretting my cocky tone.

“It means what I tell you it means,” he said.

He didn’t have to tell me, of course. I knew by then what he was going to do. What I didn’t know is why he needed me, of all people, to do it with him.

…

Lined up in the moon’s shadow, they already looked like headstones. Some straight, some crooked, tall, short.

A ruffian came out with a pile of sacks that had the word SALT printed on them in big letters, and Black Tooth said ain’t that funny now, they should enjoy that good salty taste, and they passed the sacks around and pulled them over the heads, but they were three shy, so three done without. The oldest one—the first one we helped into the wagon—he fell to his knees, wrists twisting against the ropes where me and Jep tied them. His white hair and white longshirt rippled like a torn flag of surrender. Shivering. Both lines shivering.

“Give us time to pray,” the flag pleaded to the darkness, but could barely hear him through the roaring trees, roaring creek.

The captain answered from behind the man’s back in a voice as cold as a ladle full of water fetched fresh from a spring in winter: “Be not troubled, my good man. You will have ample opportunity to compose your supplication on the way. As a matter of fact, in a few ticks of my timepiece your soul shall be free to do as it pleases, liberated as you will be from the moral constraints that encumber the living. You’re a fortunate fellow, really, to be escaping these confused times so cleanly.”

After he finished his benediction, the barrel of his pistol fell like a lever, he pulled the trigger, and the flame seemed to burst through the old man’s neck. The backbone stiffened straight as a flintlock, like the earthly body was unsure what to do next and needed a sign, and then slumped slaunchwise. The report echoed. Round the cove. Echoed.

“One less vote for King Abraham Africanus,” Black Tooth shouted. Some laughed. Some didn’t.

“Now you other good folks get on your knees and don’t turn around unless I tell you to,” Captain Widebrim ordered. “Remain calm. You’re merely here to help us sort out a few disputed matters, regardless of what that old fool thought. After we’ve completed our inquiry into the facts, you will be released to go home. I realize all this may seem a bit puzzling right now, but everything will be explained to your satisfaction in a moment.”

The captain stepped over the old man’s body and called the line back to ready. Barrels went up like a barn raising. Sweat was starting to freeze under my shirt.

Couldn’t see who it was, but a voice sounded from our line. “I thought we was taking them for a trial.”

“I now pronounce them guilty,” Black Tooth laughed.

“Yeah, guilty,” someone else said. Then a couple more shouted guilty, guilty, guilty, and in a second the whole line was a choir of coyotes howling at their cleverness.

“Get on with it,” someone said.

“Yeah. I’m freezing,” Black Tooth said.

“We got to find a way to stop this,” Jep whispered to me. “It ain’t right.”

“No, we don’t,” I said. “Point but don’t fire. It won’t be on us. None of it will be on us.”

The ruffian with morals persisted. “This is plain murder. I didn’t sign on to no plain murder.”

“You didn’t?” Captain Widebrim said. He swung his pistol to the right and fired in one motion like the hands of a grandfather clock striking three. Whoever he was, the man with scruples dropped on the spot. “There. Omission corrected. You have now signed on to at least one murder.”

This time nobody laughed.

“All right, anyone else needing a clear conscience?”

Silence. Even the wind died down.

Captain Widebrim looked directly at me. “No one? No other objections to the justice of these proceedings?”

I looked straight ahead at those withered corn stalks shaking on their knees in the freezing rain.

“Are you sure we haven’t made any mistakes here? Wouldn’t want to make any mistakes, would we? No? Then our moment of clarification has at long last arrived. Ready.”

Line of barrels went back up. The fingers of my left hand swelled such a knot that I could barely cradle the forestock. Captain Widebrim waited for a crack of thunder, the first of the evening, to roll past. Whole line of prisoners seemed to flinch at once.

“Aim.”

“Don’t fire,” I whispered to Jep. “I mean it. Don’t fire. It won’t be on me and it sure as hell won’t be on you.”

“Wonder why they don’t try to run,” Jep said.

…

One was still breathing. When the body rolled over, I saw Little Ezra trying to cover his stomach with the ropes, his face still swollen from the beating he took because of me. The shot had ripped clean through his insides. Blood that looked black in the moonlight slid onto the grass. His knees were doubled like a box turtle flipped on its back. Mouth open, moaning.

Captain Widebrim grabbed Jep by the scruff and yanked him so hard he dropped his musket. The captain offered him the handle of his revolver like he was giving him a knife to cut his own throat with. My brother just stared at it dumbfounded and teary eyed, the way a kid in the schoolhouse does when he has to recite his ABCs and doesn’t know his way around but the first two.

“Terrible way to die,” Captain Widebrim said. “Wouldn’t be Christian to allow all that suffering, would it?”

“Leave him be,” I said.

“One more entry concludes our business here. Time’s a wasting, son. Idle hands are the devil’s playground.”

“Leave him be,” I said. “He’s too young.”

“Oh, I don’t know,” Captain Widebrim said. “It never ceases to astonish me what young people are capable of doing these days.” He bore back down on Jep. “Your helpful friend over there said you were with us. True to the soil and all that. Weren’t misinformed, was I?”

More blood spreading. My knuckle throbbing.

“He ain’t involved,” I said. “He’s innocent.”

The bloodshot in the captain’s eyes lit up as if my words had just unlocked a door to perdition.

“And thereby hangs the tale, doesn’t it? Remember what I told you about not leaving any innocents to bear false witness.”

“That ain’t what I meant. We shot them for you. We both did. You’re worried we’re going to tell? We’re just as guilty as any of them. We got no reason to tell on you. You can trust us. Both of us.”

“Trust you?” the captain laughed. “You just told me three lies in the space of ten seconds. Which version of you am I supposed to trust?”

Jep started breathing in gulps, that weak-sister way he did before Ma or Eli would have to slap him upside the head and tell him to be a man.

“If you don’t take this opportunity,” Captain Widebrim said to Jep, “I’ll have no choice but to reserve a place for you amongst the rest of the honored guests at this raven’s banquet.”

“Don’t do it, Jep,” I said.

“Make your decision, son.”

When Jep reached for the pistol, I stepped up. “We don’t need your gun, sir.”

I aimed between the eyes, breathed slow and held the musket barrel steady, even though a snare drum was pounding in my chest. My mind went back to a time about maybe five or six years ago when Eli and me treed a black bear that we’d been tracking for a good hour, and just before I had a chance to take it down with one clean shot, I spotted a cub clinging to the mother’s back, and Eli said to go ahead and shoot because whether we killed the cub or not, it was doomed to die without its mother, and our living family needed the meat. As I pulled the trigger, I saw those same betrayed eyes, felt that same sickening rush of excitement in my throat. The pan flash should have cracked in my ear, but for some reason it sounded muffled, like it was fired from someone else’s gun far away. The recoil, though, was a razor blade in my fingers and shoulder. Little Ezra’s head exploded in black powder.

…

I stood there for what seemed a long time, breathing the acrid sulphur, and listening to the rapids rush over the rocks in the creek, and watching the rain soak the bloody clothes. It occurred to me that Eli might be doing the same thing at this moment on whatever battlefield he was standing.

“All right,” I said finally. “You got what you wanted. We done now?”

“I wouldn’t say done exactly,” Captain Widebrim replied.

“There are others?”

“No, but you cheated me, young man. The deed you have just performed, noble as it may be, adds nothing to the ledger.”

“What are you talking about now?”

Captain Widebrim ran his palm over the pistol barrel, like he was composing a poem while petting a favorite cat, then he returned the sidearm to the leather holster on his hip with a crisp snap. He had the look of man who had just eaten a sumptuous dinner but was only beginning to get hungry.

“I’m talking about moral imperatives, my young friend, moral imperatives.”

“Say again?”

“What difference does it make how many people you kill? Your silence already was guaranteed by that little salt escapade you and your friends went on. How many died in that misadventure? Two, three? You’ve demonstrated the ability to keep those murders secret most satisfactorily. Further misfeasance on your part was mere surplusage.”

I felt my face burn red. “You knew about that?”

“Of course. It was the first thing your half-wit friend Odum told me. And I must say it’s been most amusing to watch you wriggle on the hook these past few hours. Well worth the risk I took bringing you along.”

“I didn’t kill them.”

“Be honest. You were part of a conspiracy, not so different from the one you have just willingly joined. The distinctions you seek to draw are merely a lawyer’s equivocation.”

I didn’t even bother to varnish my words now. “And you let these here die for it? Knowing they had nothing to do with it? You didn’t even ask me to name the others. What kind of Christian are you?”

I meant the words to sting, but Captain Widebrim’s face remained emotionless. “A better one than you, I reckon. Examine the evidence, salt marauder. By rights, you should be as dead as any of this rabble, yet I don’t recall you vouchsafing for their innocence. What’s your Good Book say about a man giving up his life for another? You’re hardly a paragon of rectitude by that standard.

“Come to think, I’d say I have the decidedly better claim. My orders were to punish an offense against the state by a backsliding, stiff-necked, and unrepentant population. For reasons that should be obvious, a mission of that sort calls for a swiftly executed terror, not a time-consuming separation of sheep from goats. Read your Bible thoroughly and tell me that’s not so. No, efficiency was my mandate, and I upheld it scrupulously without regard to personal feelings. I won’t call it exemplary devotion to duty, for that would be immodest, but devotion nonetheless. Self-negation, really. I suppose it’s how a saint must feel. You, on the other hand, were under no orders but your own, and you tried to get away with as much as you could without calling attention to yourself. You think you’re my moral better?”

“We needed that salt.”

“So did our troops. We all need something.” Captain Widebrim motioned to Jep. “And, as I suspect you know by this juncture, what I still need—what I have been wanting all along—is your little brother there. Your poor, blubbering brother. He’s not like us, is he? To his eyes, a lie is a lie. He requires a truth so clear and a guilt so horrible he will never speak it to anyone. Either that or he must be rendered unable to speak to anyone again, and that’s such a crude expedient, isn’t it? So, alas, it appears I’ll have to settle for your word on it now, tarnished as it may be.” Captain Widebrim gestured with an open palm like an undertaker showing his top-dollar casket to a rube. “As you can see, we’ve run out of incriminating opportunities.”

Jep was sobbing, and I confess at that moment I was embarrassed to be with him.

Captain Widebrim continued. “So I have your oath on it then? He’ll stay quiet? He’ll harbor your blood guilt as if it were his own? For the rest of his days? I’d call that a right magnanimous offer, considering the alternative, but someone in my position can afford a measure of beneficence now and again. Mercy is the prerogative of the superior man.”

He retrieved two yellow gauntlets that had been folded in his belt, pulled them over his flexing fingers, and extended his right hand with disgusting elegance. I backed a half step. I felt like a fox trying to chew himself out of a leg trap.

“Oh, please,” he said, “don’t tell me you’re an ungracious victor as well as a fraud. Permit yourself at least some return for all your fine efforts. It’s not everyone who would have gone to such extremes to shield a loved one from the terrible crimes life demands.”

I held out my good hand and we shook on the pact like rival bankers, though I couldn’t bring myself to look at Jep while I did it.

“Can we go now?” I said. “Please can we go?”

“Yeah,” sneered Black Tooth. “Can we go now? Pretty please, can we go now? Or are you two philosophers going to gabble all night till we freeze our asses off?”

“Of course, you can leave,” Captain Widebrim said to me. “You volunteered for this duty, remember?”

He said I done right, and how did it feel to be a rebel in the real war now, and he extemporized about how it would have been a tragedy to waste the lives of any more of our young people, they being the future of our new nation and all, and shouldn’t I be fetching a rag to wipe my blubbering brother’s eyes with before he brings any more weakling dishonor to our cause.

When I couldn’t stomach any more, I turned away, but then I heard an explosion and spun back around. Captain Widebrim was falling backward, holding his belly, until he crumpled next to Little Ezra, harmless as a heap of clothes wanting a scrub-washing. Saw the smoke curl from Jep’s musket, curl for a second, then was sheared off by the wind like it was never there.

“I didn’t cry,” he sniffled.

…

“Jesus, you fool,” Mister Odum shouted.

Sensed two shadows—two shadows of rifle barrels—coming up behind me. Heard the levers pumping. No time to reload. Wouldn’t even have gotten in the powder. And to tell the honest truth, I felt relieved, like a contagion had been flushed from my lungs. At least Jep and me wouldn’t have to live with what we done here. Not for very long, anyway.

As I waited for the shots, Sergeant Towhead stepped past us and knelt over the captain’s body. “Well, lookee here,” he said, opening the buttons on the captain’s bloody coat. “You seeing this, Eustus?”

“I see it,” the other said.

Sergeant Towhead pointed to the Little Dry Branch as the freezing wind rifled through his hair. “Shot must’ve come from over there. Behind those trees. Or maybe those rocks. Whaddya think there, Eustus?”

“You say so.”

“Sharpshooters behind every rock, every tree in these treacherous parts. Never know when you’ll find yourself bushed.”

“Yeah, never know.”

“He would have killed you both regardless,” Sergeant Towhead said without looking back at me. “That little speech was just sport with him. But it could work out better this way for us. The official story might just hold if they find a musket ball from your people in him.”

“What official story?”

“The one where we were taking them in for questioning and their friends bushed us out of nowhere. You saw that, didn’t you? I’m sure you did. But make sure anyone who doesn’t believe you finds that fine, round ball in him. Nice touch, really.”

Sergeant Towhead told Mister Odum to reach him the captain’s hat, and he wiped the blood from the brim. “We’ll be taking them guns now, boys, if you’uns got no further use for them this evening.”

“We need them, sir.”

“Do tell.”

“They’s worth twenty dollar,” I lied.

“You just gave me another reason.”

“We can’t hunt without our guns.”

“You can’t keep the meat through the winter without salt, but we’re heading back for that little hoard you’ve got stashed under your cabin just the same. What’s the difference how you starve?”

I glared at Odum. He shrugged.

“Now old Captain High-Horse here didn’t want to sully his gloved hands with a commodity as dirty as purloined goods,” Sergeant Towhead said, “but I think we’ll just let his principles remain here with him. Whaddya say there, Eusty? Salt is gold in these parts. With the embargo and all, salt is king. Hence all the fuss.” He turned his back, did a half-jig step and bent the widebrim to make it stay against the wind. “Yessir, sharpshooter behind every rock, every tree. Whaddya think there, Eusty?”

“Good to be git is what I think. I hate these mountains, and I hate this war.”

The soldiers and the ruffians started back to the road where they had left the horses and mules and wagon, disappearing into the shadows and thickets and thrashing trees. Mister Odum said we’d best walk alongside his mule, but I said no, the Spillcorns make their own way. “Well, don’t thank me,” he said. “Alls I did was save your sorry lives.”

Me and Jep stood in the rain with the bodies until Odum was out of sight. There were no words, so we didn’t talk. I thought of saying a prayer, but I didn’t reckon any god worthy of the name would want to hear from me now.

Came to me another vision of Eli just then. In a place such as this, with men such as that. Trudging into a wood, out of a wood. Lying on his back. In a downpour. Huge mud drops bouncing back at the black sky. Eyes staring up. And then that picture turned into another pair of eyes, still-open eyes, accusing eyes, the ones we were sure to find staring, lifeless and gray, when we got back to our cabin in the morning. The throbbing in my hand was back now. Long, slow. Long, slow.

Peter Robbins is a writer, retired lawyer, onetime newspaper reporter, and unappreciated polymath living in Southern Appalachia. This is his first published short story. His news stories, features, commentaries, and award-winning columns have appeared in the Macon Telegraph & News, the Richmond News Leader, the Mountain Xpress, the Madison County News-Record & Sentinel, and the Daily Illini.